American studies scholar wins two national awards for book on 20th-century culture wars

Author: Adah McMillan

Man in glasses standing at lectern, gesturing with a pen in front of a blackboard.Man in glasses standing at lectern, gesturing with a pen in front of a blackboard.

Anthony Petro, an associate professor in the Department of American Studies at the University of Notre Dame, has received two prizes and an honorable mention for his second monograph, which reframes the culture wars of the late 20th century through artists’ stories.

Provoking Religion: Sex, Art, and the Culture Wars (Oxford University Press, 2025) won the American Academy of Religion’s 2026 Religion and the Arts Book Award and the Popular Culture Association’s Best Single Work, Anthology, Multi-Authored, or Edited Book in LGBTQ Studies award, and it received an honorable mention in the British Association of American Studies book awards.

AAR called Petro’s work “a master class in close readings of style, history, and an imaginative use of religion as an analytic category.”

“No one writes a book just to get an award, but getting such recognition from peers in your field definitely makes the many years of researching and writing feel all the more meaningful,” Petro said.

Petro teaches courses on U.S. religious history, gender and sexuality studies, the long 1980s, and visual cultures. His research lives at the intersection of these interests, and his first book, After the Wrath of God: AIDS, Sexuality, and American Religion, provides a glimpse into the history of religion and the AIDS crisis in the United States.

Similarly, Provoking Religion explores a key period in modern history. At that time, conservative Christian leaders in both the government and national media attacked shifting sex and gender norms, in part by denouncing feminist and queer artists. These subversive artists confronted sexism, homophobia, and racism as their work was called sacrilegious or pornographic by conservatives.

“I’m grateful to have such generous and incisive colleagues in American studies and at Notre Dame more broadly. I couldn’t imagine a better place to do this work and to have the good fortune to teach such wonderful students!”

- Anthony Petro, associate professor of American studies

Petro argues that their art was not separate from the sacred, as certain Christian criticisms would suggest, but instead displayed alternative visions of religion and spirituality. He portrays the culture wars as a struggle to “define the relationship between the sacred and the political,” rather than a battle between the religious and secular.

Provoking Religion takes readers through the several disciplines Petro traverses in his scholarship, and the book’s three recognitions speak to the appeal of his approach.

The Religion and the Arts Book Award highlights Petro’s status as a religion scholar, coming from the largest academic society for the study of religion. Other finalists in the award category wrote about subjects ranging from early American Protestantism to Sikh ritual chants.

“They represent a fascinating range of topics in the study of religion, and I am so thrilled to be among them,” Petro said.

The award from the Popular Culture Association confirms that Provoking Religion resonates with scholars outside of religious studies and celebrates his focus on art. And the honorable mention from a British organization demonstrates the book’s positive reception among scholars of American studies internationally.

“Provoking Religion is a consequential book for many fields,” the AAR award jury wrote.

Petro continues to illustrate the 20th-century culture wars in his current project, tentatively titled “Wild Devotions: A Cultural Biography of Kathryn Hulme, Mystic, Crocodile, Catholic, and Bestselling Author of The Nun’s Story.” The book will focus on the life of Catholic writer Kathryn Hulme, answering questions about her life and legacy while examining issues related to religion, culture, and sexuality.

Since Petro joined Notre Dame’s faculty last year, he’s found the American studies department to be the perfect place for unearthing the pieces of history that never stop fascinating him — learning how religion has shaped the American past and the world of today.

“I’m grateful to have such generous and incisive colleagues in American studies and at Notre Dame more broadly,” Petro said. “I couldn’t imagine a better place to do this work and to have the good fortune to teach such wonderful students!”

Originally published by Adah McMillan at al.nd.edu on October 16, 2026.